JOURNAL OF ICON STUDIES
The Journal of Icon Studies is an online, peer-reviewed publication dedicated to the interdisciplinary study of icons around the globe, from the Byzantine period to the modern era. It serves as an international forum for new scholarship on the theoretical, theological, and historical significance of icons, their place within a broad cultural and artistic context, and their conservation, collecting, and exhibiting. In addition, the Journal includes reviews of books and exhibitions, archival discoveries, and translations of primary documents.
The Journal is published annually by the Museum of Russian Icons in Clinton, MA. The language of publication is English.
Edited by Wendy Salmond
- Amy Singleton Adams, College of the Holy Cross
- Elena Boeck, DePaul University
- Robin Cormack, Cambridge University
- Michael Flier, Harvard University
- Nancy Patterson-Ševčenko, International Center of Medieval Art
- Sarah Pratt, University of Southern California
- Wendy Salmond, Editor, Chapman University
- Vera Shevzov, Smith College
- Engelina Smirnova, Lomonosov Moscow State University and Institute of Art Studies, Moscow
- Oksana Smirnova, Andrey Rublev Museum of Ancient Russian Culture and Art
- Raoul N. Smith, Northeastern University
- Oleg Tarasov, Institute of Slavic Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences
Journal of Icon Studies (JIS) is an open-access publication and adheres to the Budapest Open Access Initiative (BOAI) definition of open access. This means that users may “read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts” of its articles. JIS does not charge readers or institutions for access to the Journal. All content published in JIS is freely available immediately following publication (there is no embargo period).
Authors retain the copyright of the content they publish with JIS with no restrictions. They allow JIS to distribute and continue to make available the article in perpetuity under the Journal’s preferred license (Creative Commons CC BY International 4.0 license). After publication in JIS, authors are free to republish their material elsewhere, providing an acknowledgment that the article or review was first published in JIS is made.
All articles and reviews in JIS are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Public License (CC BY 4.0) unless otherwise noted. All images are reproduced with the permission of the rights holders acknowledged in captions or are reproduced under license and are expressly excluded from the CC BY 4.0 license covering the rest of this publication. These images may not be reproduced, copied, transmitted, or manipulated without consent from the owners, who reserve all rights, and outside the terms of any specified license. It is the responsibility of the author to cite the relevant copyright when using images and other digital materials.
Journal of Icons Studies is a digital publication intended to be experienced online and referenced digitally. PDFs are provided for ease of reading offline. Please do not reference the PDF in academic citations: we recommend using DOIs (digital object identifiers) provided within the online article. These unique alphanumeric strings identify content and provide a persistent link to a location on the internet. A DOI is guaranteed never to change, so you can use it to link permanently to electronic documents. We ask users to identify the use of materials made available through this website and to provide appropriate credit to the author and the publication so that others may find and use our resources. The Journal is made available free of charge.
Contributions to the Journal of Icon Studies are solicited in all areas of icon research. Submissions and any questions should be sent by email to the Editor, Wendy Salmond, at research(at)museumofrussianicons.org.
The Journal of Icon Studies follows the editing practices of The Chicago Manual of Style, 16th ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2010). Refer to Webster’s Third New International Dictionary or Webster’s Fourth for spelling. For transliteration from Russian to English, please use the Library of Congress transliteration system.
All submissions must be sent electronically via email or large-file transfer service such as YouSendIt.com. The Journal of Icon Studies does not accept hard-copy submissions.
The manuscript in Microsoft Word, all elements of which must be double spaced (including endnotes and numbered captions) with a maximum of 16,000 words, including endnotes. Please do not send PDFs since these files cannot be altered to preserve anonymity during blind peer-editing;
An illustration list in Microsoft Word, also double spaced, with a maximum of 20 images; A Microsoft Word file no larger than 10 MB containing all illustrations. If the file is larger than 10 MB, the JIS cannot send it to peer reviewers since many institutional firewalls block files larger than 10 MB.
Submissions should include a cover sheet with the author’s name, a 50-word biographical statement (double spaced), and the manuscript’s total word count, including all text and notes. The author’s name should appear only on a separate cover sheet. In addition, the title of the article, but not the author’s name, should be repeated on the first page of the text.
A 100-word abstract of the article with a list of keywords
All submitted articles are given an initial review by the Editor of the Journal of Icon Studies. This initial evaluation is guided by the following criteria:
- The material is original and important.
- The writing is grammatically correct and clear.
- The data are appropriate to the topic and factually accurate.
- The conclusions are reasonable and clearly supported by the data.
- The topic has general interest to the icon research community.
The Editor assesses the paper’s initial eligibility for publication based on these criteria. Manuscripts not satisfying these criteria are rejected, and a notice sent to the author. If the manuscript satisfies most of these criteria, it is sent to three members of the Editorial Board with knowledge of the submission topic. They may, in turn, submit it to outside reviewers. The identity of the specific reviewers is kept confidential from the author(s), just as author identities are kept confidential from the reviewers. Reviewers must maintain confidentiality about the manuscripts they review and must not divulge any information about a specific manuscript or its contents to anyone not involved in the review process.
If the manuscript is accepted, the author is notified, and the publication process is begun. The manuscript is returned to the author for revision with reviewer comments if it is accepted with revisions. Authors are responsible for all statements made in their work, including changes made during editing. The final form rests in the hands of the Editor of the Journal after consultation with the author and reviewers.
PUBLICATIONS ETHICS STATEMENT
The Journal of Icon Studies expects its editors, authors, and reviewers to commit to and respect the following principles.
- The work submitted for publication in JIS is original;
- The work has not been previously published (unless it is a translation published in accordance with the Journal’s mission to serve as a bridge between different national and academic milieus and is referenced as such);
- The authors will refrain from submitting the work for publication elsewhere while JIS reviews it and following a positive outcome of the review process;
- All sources in the manuscript are properly cited and referenced in accordance with JIS style;
- The editor of JIS will evaluate submitted manuscripts solely on their intellectual merits and the extent to which they foster JIS’s mission;
- The editor of JIS will maintain strict confidentiality in all matters pertaining to the publication of the manuscript;
- Each reviewer will evaluate the submitted manuscript solely based on criteria outlined in the Journal’s peer review form;
- Each reviewer will notify the editor of any potential conflicts of interest;
- Each reviewer will maintain strict confidentiality in matters pertaining to the review process;
- Each reviewer will notify the editor of any potential reason to reject the manuscript.